Who gets to see the records behind Spotify’s royalty calculations is now on a shorter timetable. A new order puts a Monday deadline on responses to a request for documents from the Mechanical Licensing Collective.
In its November 18 order, the Copyright Royalty Judges moved that deadline to November 23 at noon. The order does not specify a time zone and allows no replies unless the judges request them.
The National Music Publishers’ Association and Nashville Songwriters Association International are seeking the subpoena in Phonorecords V, the proceeding that will determine U.S. statutory mechanical royalty rates for 2028-32. Those royalties concern musical compositions, a different set of rights from the recordings listeners play.
Digital Music News reported November 18 that the groups want bundle-related documents exchanged in the MLC’s separate lawsuit against Spotify. That dispute concerns Spotify’s treatment of subscriptions combining music and audiobooks, including the MLC’s claims about underpaid mechanical royalties.
The same report describes Spotify defending the earlier bundling framework and proposing to retain it in the next rate period. The new order establishes a faster response schedule; it does not grant the subpoena, resolve the underlying payment dispute or award royalties.
Scapi has covered another part of this fight over streaming income before. In October 2020, we reported on UMAW’s Justice at Spotify campaign, which demanded higher pay and more transparency about the contracts behind streaming revenue.
Our March 2021 report previewed its planned demonstrations, including an action outside Spotify’s Chicago office. The organization was then called the Union of Musicians and Allied Workers and now uses United Musicians and Allied Workers.
UMAW’s current streaming-pay campaign advocates an additional royalty paid directly to recording musicians. That proposal concerns a separate payment route from the composition royalties in the CRB proceeding; the November 18 order names NMPA and NSAI as the groups seeking the subpoena.
The connection is the demand to make the arrangements behind streaming pay visible. For this records request, the next step is the response deadline on November 23, followed by whatever decision the judges make about access to the documents.
Archive photograph of Spotify’s Stockholm headquarters, April 5, 2024. Photo: Goombah / Wikimedia Commons, CC0 1.0. Reduced resolution; full original framing.


Be First to Comment